Compare Central Heating

The easiest way to understand central heating is to categorize the different systems based on the energy they use for heating.

Heating by burning wood, oil or gas

  • Fuel (wood, oil, gas, etc.) is burned in a boiler to heat water (sometimes gas) then transmitted through radiators or underfloor heating.
  • It requires a system built around a boiler and pipe network.
  • It is renowned for its reliability and efficiency.
  • Ecological heating using wood is considered a renewable energy.

Electric heating

  • Integrates the functions of heat production and distribution in the same device: radiator or underfloor heating.
  • Unrestrictive: just needs to be plugged into the mains electricity supply.
  • Sometimes criticized for producing dry heat. However, new models are more comfortable. It is always possible to use a humidifier.

Renewable heating

Two main types:

    • Heat pump: heats the whole house.
    • Solar: not normally sufficient to heat the whole house. Needs to be supplemented by an auxiliary heater .

Technologically they are more complex and therefore more expensive to buy. However, much cheaper to use.

Comparative performance and environmental impact of heating boiler, electric and renewable energy

PERFORMANCE

ENVIRONMENT

COMBUSTION SYSTEM (BOILER)

Gas

Very good

Poor

  • Fossil fuels CO2 emissions (greenhouse gas emissions)

LPG tank

Fuel

Wood

Very Good

  • Renewable energy, good CO2 balance

ELECTRIC

Very good 
Good rapid heating

Good
Clean energy, especially if nuclear

RENEWABLE ENERGY

Solar

Not enough to heat a home
Need extra heating
OK for DHW

Fine

Heat pump

  • Good
  • Need for additional heating for certain types of pumps or harsh winter climates
  • Much higher performance *

Very Good

  • Renewable energy, but works partly on electricity

* Yield = ratio between energy consumption and heat output depends on the source of energy and the quality of the product.

Request a quote